WMPA is a non-profit organization incorporated in the State of Hawaii dedicated to preserving, protecting and restoring the natural and cultural environment of West Maui including Land Conservation and educational activities related thereto.

Mailing Address :

P. O. Box 11150,
Lahaina, Maui, HI  96761


Mayor’s Statement on Lahaina Injection Well US Supreme Court Oral Arguments

November 6, 2019

Oral arguments were heard today before the US Supreme Court in a case involving Maui County’s Lahaina injection wells and the interpretation of the Clean Water Act.

Maui Mayor Michael Victorino issued a statement today saying the case is about “home rule for the management of groundwater.” He released the following statement this morning:

“It was an honor to be present and witness the Supreme Court justices’ consideration of the issues raised by the County of Maui, the plaintiffs and federal regulators,” said Mayor Victorino. “Their questions were insightful, and I felt that they truly understood the complexity of the issues in this case and the potential effects of the expansion of the Clean Water Act on governmental entities and private properties.”

“Maui County has been an environmental steward since the 1970s when ocean sewage outfalls were abandoned in favor of wastewater reclamation facilities. Leaving this litigation unsettled would leave unanswered questions that would make Maui County taxpayers vulnerable to more lawsuits, uncertain regulatory requirements and staggering costs – all for what would be a negligible environmental benefit.” “The Lahaina Wastewater Reclamation Facility is a model in employing treatment technologies, including ultraviolet light disinfection, to transform wastewater into the highest quality recycled water in the State of Hawaii. This direction was a conscious decision made more than 40 years ago by visionary leaders in our community, and today, the County’s water reuse program is the most robust in the State of Hawaii. One of the major concerns I have had since the plaintiffs brought this suit in 2012 was the potentially devastating effect on our water reuse program.”

“This case has never been about winning or losing. It’s about clarity in the law so that we can move forward, confident as to the clear boundaries of the law so we can implement our programs and practices accordingly. I look forward to the Court’s decision.”

The court will decide whether the Clean Water Act regulates pollution discharges that “indirectly” enter protected waters.

The lawsuit was filed by the Hawaii Wildlife Fund against Maui County over the discharge of treated sewage into the ocean via groundwater beneath the facility saying it has devastated a formerly pristine reef


County officials say a final decision is not expected until the spring.

A transcript of the hearing is available HERE


An audio recording will become available on Friday, Nov. 8, HERE


Original article URL:




WMPA in the News
West Maui Injection Wells
Contact WMPA


© copyright 2005    West Maui Preservation Association, Inc.    A non-profit corporation.